If you don't remember your password, you can reset it by entering your email address and clicking the Reset Password button. You will then receive an email that contains a secure link for resetting your password
If the address matches a valid account an email will be sent to __email__ with instructions for resetting your password
Immune cells are present in normal breast tissue and in breast carcinoma. The nature and distribution of the immune cell subtypes in these tissues are reviewed to promote a better understanding of their important role in breast cancer prevention and treatment. We conducted a review of the literature to define the type, location, distribution, and role of immune cells in normal breast tissue and in in situ and invasive breast cancer. Immune cells in normal breast tissue are located predominantly within the epithelial component in breast ductal lobules. Immune cell subtypes representing innate immunity (NK, CD68+, and CD11c+ cells) and adaptive immunity (most commonly CD8+, but CD4+ and CD20+ as well) are present; CD8+ cells are the most common subtype and are primarily effector memory cells. Immune cells may recognize neoantigens and endogenous and exogenous ligands and may serve in chronic inflammation and immunosurveillance. Progression to breast cancer is characterized by increased immune cell infiltrates in tumor parenchyma and stroma, including CD4+ and CD8+ granzyme B+ cytotoxic T cells, B cells, macrophages and dendritic cells. Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in breast cancer may serve as prognostic indicators for response to chemotherapy and for survival. Experimental strategies of adoptive transfer of breast tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte may allow regression of metastatic breast cancer and encourage development of innovative T-cell strategies for the immunotherapy of breast cancer. In conclusion, immune cells in breast tissues play an important role throughout breast carcinogenesis. An understanding of these roles has important implications for the prevention and the treatment of breast cancer.
Most breast cancers arise in the breast milk ducts, either as ductal carcinoma-in-situ (DCIS) or as invasive ductal carcinoma. Breast cancer develops through the accumulation of mutational changes, most commonly in the ductal epithelium. The development and progression of these changes can be influenced by multiple elements in the ductal microenvironment, both cellular such as immune cells, adipocytes, fibroblasts, and the microbiome, and soluble including growth factors, cytokines, chemokines, and prostaglandins. Among the most important of these elements are the immune cells, which are considered to play a critical role throughout the course of breast carcinogenesis, beginning in normal breast tissue with immunosurveillance and continuing through primary and metastatic breast cancer. The ductal cellular layer in the normal breast contains a significant immune cell population consisting of CD8+ and CD4+ T cells, B cells, dendritic cells, macrophages, NK (natural killer) cells, and other immune cell subtypes.
Analysis of immune cells from human mammary ductal epithelial organoids reveals Vdelta2+ T cells that efficiently target breast carcinoma cells in the presence of bisphosphonate.
Together, these immune cells provide important innate and adaptive immunity to the epithelial layer for both protection against exogenous and endogenous agents, and elimination of transformed cells. An understanding of the immune cellular population in normal breast tissue may thus have important implications for breast cancer prevention, improved methods of risk assessment, and the regulation of breast carcinogenesis.
Progression through the carcinogenic pathway from normal breast tissue to breast cancer is accompanied by quantitative and qualitative changes in the nature and location of the immune cell population, including an increase in immune cell content in both the parenchymal and stromal compartments. The immune cell infiltration in breast cancer consists of multiple cellular subtypes, including CD3+ (CD4+ and CD8+) cells, B cells, monocytes/macrophages, dendritic cells, and NK cells.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
The presence of multiple immune cell subtypes in both the parenchyma and stroma places these cells in close proximity to tumor cells and other cells in the microenvironment, and allows these cells to influence tumor growth in multiple ways, either directly through CD4+ and CD8+ cell-mediated cytotoxicity, or indirectly through immunosuppressive or immunostimulatory actions from secreted cytokines, growth factors and other agents. Their distribution and characteristics may also vary according to the subtype of breast cancer, their estrogen responsiveness, their mutational load, and the formation of tertiary lymphoid structures. Importantly, detailed analysis of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) has demonstrated prognostic properties for these cells,
Prognostic and predictive value of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in a phase III randomized adjuvant breast cancer trial in node-positive breast cancer comparing the addition of docetaxel to doxorubicin with doxorubicin-based chemotherapy: BIG 02-98.
Prognostic value of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in triple-negative breast cancers from two phase III randomized adjuvant breast cancer trials: ECOG 2197 and ECOG 1199.
and collecting and administering TILs to patients has resulted in durable complete regression of solid tumors as well providing knowledge to allow development of cellular therapy with gene-modified T-cell receptors (TCRs) for treatment of breast and other cancers.
Together these findings indicate an important role for immune cells in the breast throughout breast carcinogenesis, and significant changes in these cells during the course of these events. To clarify these significant properties, we have conducted a review of the literature of the nature and characteristics of ductal immune cells in normal breast tissue, of TILs in breast cancer, and the efforts to translate the latter findings into both valuable prognostic indicators and successful immunotherapeutic treatment options for breast cancer, including ongoing and innovative trials at our institution.
Materials and Methods
A literature search was conducted through PubMed and cross-references to identify publications describing the nature and distribution of immune cells in normal breast tissue and in breast cancer. Normal breast tissue may include tissue from women at normal risk (such as from reduction mammoplasty), as well as from the contralateral breast or from tissue adjacent to a breast cancer in women with a breast cancer. For studies of breast cancer, emphasis was placed on immune cells in the primary tumor.
Results and Discussion
Immune Cells in the Normal Breast
Breast Ductal Anatomy
The ductal anatomy and its relationship to the distribution of immune cells in the normal breast is illustrated in Figure 1. The principle unit in the breast ductal system is the acini, which drains into an intralobular and then the extralobular duct; together, these structures constitute the terminal ductal lobular unit (TDLU). The intralobular terminal ducts are lined by cuboidal epithelium, and the extralobular terminal duct and major ducts are lined by pseudostratified columnar epithelium or a double layer of cuboidal epithelium. The TDLU is considered to be the predominant site of the origin of breast cancer.
Overexpressed genes associated with hormones in terminal ductal lobular units identified by global transcriptome analysis: an insight into the anatomic origin of breast cancer.
The vast majority of breast cancers are carcinomas that arise in the epithelium and include in-situ and invasive ductal and invasive lobular carcinoma. Gene expression studies have indicated that hormone-related pathways are highly enriched in the TDLU, including various hormone-related genes that are associated with breast carcinogenesis. It has been proposed that the imbalanced hormone-reactions may result in the early onset of neoplastic transformation that occurs mostly in breast TDLUs.
Overexpressed genes associated with hormones in terminal ductal lobular units identified by global transcriptome analysis: an insight into the anatomic origin of breast cancer.
The breast ducts are surrounded by stroma that consists of extracellular matrix (ECM), fibroblasts, adipocytes, immune cells, microbiome, and blood vessels. The breast ducts and stroma together comprise the breast microenvironment.
Figure 1Nature and Distribution of Immune Cells in Normal Breast Tissue. A Variety of Immune Cells are Present in Normal Breast Tissue, including Both Lymphocytes and Myeloid-Derived Cells. Immune Cells are Located Primarily Within the Ductal Epithelium (Intraepithelial) but May be Present in the Stroma as Well (Not Depicted). The Stromal Extracellular Matrix (ECM) Also Contains a Variety of Cell Types and Structures that May Interact With Immune Cells and the Epithelium. Adapted From Degnim et al
Distribution of Immune Cells within Normal Breast Tissue
Normal breast tissue contains immune cells of both myeloid (monocytes, macrophages, dendritic cells) and lymphoid (T lymphocytes and B lymphocytes) lineage. Immune cells in normal breast tissue are predominantly localized to the lobules rather than the stroma and fat (Figure 1),
comprise cells of both the innate and adaptive immune systems, and thus may potentially provide protection against bacterial and other pathogens as well as immune surveillance and elimination of epithelial cells with mutational changes. Immune cells identified in early studies were predominantly lymphocytes,
Analysis of immune cells from human mammary ductal epithelial organoids reveals Vdelta2+ T cells that efficiently target breast carcinoma cells in the presence of bisphosphonate.
Overall, immune CD45+ cells are prominent among the ductal epithelial cells. CD8+ T cells are the most common cells in all series, and in the study by Degnim et al,
CD8+ T cells and CD11c+ (dendritic) cells were present in virtually all lobules and among the most numerous across lobules, while CD68+ cells (macrophages/monocytes) were also numerous across lobules; CD4+ and CD20+ cells were less frequent. They also found both dendritic cells and CD8+ cells were consistently observed in intimate association with the epithelium of lobular acini and were primarily located at the basal aspect of the epithelium. The anatomical distribution of immune cells in normal breast tissue and their relationship to epithelial cells is depicted in Figure 1. The presence of the immune cells in the in TDLU places them at the predominant site of the origin of breast cancer - TDLU epithelial
Overexpressed genes associated with hormones in terminal ductal lobular units identified by global transcriptome analysis: an insight into the anatomic origin of breast cancer.
Analysis of immune cells from human mammary ductal epithelial organoids reveals Vdelta2+ T cells that efficiently target breast carcinoma cells in the presence of bisphosphonate.
using flow cytometry of breast tissue organoids from reduction mammoplasty specimens, reported that CD8+ cells represented 75% of CD3+ cells; essentially all of the CD8α+ cells expressed CD8+β, indicating they were distinct from intestinal intraepithelial cells, which are CD8+αα.
examined normal breast tissue either adjacent to breast cancer or from prophylactic mastectomy specimens and found CD3+ (CD4+ and CD8+) cells were the most common, while myeloid-lineage cells including macrophages, dendritic cells and neutrophils were also prominent. The distribution of immune cell types thus appears to be quite consistent across multiple types of normal breast tissue. Interestingly, in the study of normal breast organoids by Zumwalde et al, the authors identified an important subtype of CD3+ cells, γδ T cells. The TCRs of these cells consists of γ and δ chains rather than the conventional α and β chains, and the receptor is considered to act as a pattern recognition receptor and a bridge between innate and adaptive immune responses.
Analysis of immune cells from human mammary ductal epithelial organoids reveals Vdelta2+ T cells that efficiently target breast carcinoma cells in the presence of bisphosphonate.
Immunogenicity of Immune Cells in Normal Breast Tissue
An important question is the immunogenicity of the immune cells in normal breast tissue. It is noted that the immune cells in the breast ducts are in proximity to draining lymph nodes in the ipsilateral axilla and mediastinum, and thus all of the principle cellular and lymphatic components necessary for adaptive cellular immune response are present within the ductal system. In the study by Zumwalde et al
Analysis of immune cells from human mammary ductal epithelial organoids reveals Vdelta2+ T cells that efficiently target breast carcinoma cells in the presence of bisphosphonate.
further analysis of the CD8+ T cells indicated they were almost exclusively CD45RO+/CD27− cells, and thus were effector memory T cells (TEM). The presence of TEM in the intraepithelial lymphocyte population of the normal breast indicates these cells have been antigen-activated, as well as indicating the presence of a dynamic immune network between ductal epithelium and regional lymph nodes. Importantly, TEM may persist for considerable periods of time,
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
have shown that the CD3+ population of cells in normal breast tissue are granzyme B+ cells and thus have cytotoxic functions, suggesting an important protective role for these intraepithelial immune cells. There are several potential sources of antigens for activation of these CD8+ T cells, both exogenous (eg, viral, bacterial) and endogenous (nuclear and cytosolic proteins, DNA, extracellular proteins). Neoantigens, for example, could arise through mutational changes in ductal epithelium from exposure to estrogens and other carcinogens.
A recent review has demonstrated that normal breast tissue at normal risk for breast cancer (such as from a reduction mammoplasty) as well as normal breast tissue at increased risk for breast cancer (such as normal breast tissue adjacent to breast cancer) contain widespread genomic changes including loss of heterozygosity, small segmental deletions, DNA methylation, and telomere shortening.
This could provide an excellent source of neoantigens through associated frameshift or other mutational changes. In addition, the release of damage associated– or pathogen-associated molecular patterns from injured or dying epithelial or microbial cells may be recognized by macrophages (also present among ductal intraepithelial immune cells), eliciting release of cytokines and chemokines, production of chronic inflammation, and production of reactive oxygen species and reactive nitrogen intermediates, which may then cause mutations in neighboring epithelial cells.
the consistent presence of CD8+ cells and dendritic cells, interspersed within the breast epithelium, strongly suggests a role for antigen presentation and immune effector function, as well as stress response and maintenance of epithelial integrity. In a subsequent study by Degnim et al,
they compared the distribution of immune cells in the lobules of women with benign breast disease to breast samples from women with no known breast abnormalities and found benign breast disease lobules showed greater densities of CD8+ T cells, CD11c+ dendritic cells, CD20+ B cells, and CD68+ macrophages compared to the normal controls.
The authors concluded that elevated infiltration of both innate and adaptive immune effectors in benign breast disease tissues suggests an immunogenic microenvironment. Finally, it has also been shown that many of the mutational changes observed in normal high risk breast tissue are also present in the adjacent breast cancer, thus providing a potentially comparable immunogenic environment for immune cells.
in a study of normal breast tissue from prophylactic mastectomy tissue, observed a large number of normal breast tissue resident immune cell states, including 13 myeloid and 19 T-cell clusters that were not observed in circulation or in the secondary lymphoid tissue. The set of clusters found in normal breast tissue cells represented a subset of those observed in the breast cancers, supporting the widespread immunogenic environment of these tissues.
Intraepithelial Immune Cells and the Microenvironment
The immune cells within the intraepithelial layer are also surrounded by, and may be influenced by, major components of the microenvironment including the ECM and the interstitial matrix (Figure 1). The ECM consists of the ductal and endothelial basement membranes, and the interstitial matrix is comprised of connective tissue and cellular components (fibroblast, adipocyte, endothelial, inflammatory).
A dynamic interaction is thought to exist between the multiple components of the microenvironment, which serves to maintain and promote the contribution of each component. The components of the microenvironment are also considered to play a significant role during breast carcinogenesis. With progression of the epithelial cells in the carcinogenic pathway, there is increasing influence of these components, including the ECM, fibroblasts, and adipocytes on transformed cells. As Ghajar and Bissell
have pointed out, simple changes in ECM composition can alter diffusion and permeability through the ECM, and diffusion restrictions could foster tumorigenesis over short- and long-term scales by restricting clearance of factors secreted by enveloped cells. Fibroblasts, a major component of the ECM, can be reprogrammed into cancer-associated fibroblasts by cytokines and growth factors secreted by transformed epithelial cells.
Adipocytes are also important components of the ECM and are in close proximity to epithelial cells, tumor and immune cells. Breast cancer cells induce production of endocrine and paracrine enzymes and bioactive lipids by adipocytes, which in turn drive increased growth and invasion of tumor cells.
Leptin is also an important secretory product of adipocytes, which can stimulate production of several proinflammatory factors including interleukin (IL)-1, IL-6, and tumor necrosis factor (TNF) α.
Obesity is an important risk factor for breast cancer in postmenopausal women and may promote procarcinogenic processes in adipocytes. Several factors, including leptin, TNFα, IL-6, and resistin, are secreted by normal adipocytes, and are increased with obesity and have procarcinogenic effects.
Together, these findings indicate a diverse population of cells within the ductal epithelial layer and microenvironment of normal breast tissue that interact to play a major role in early breast carcinogenesis.
Estrogenic Effects on Normal Breast Immune Cells
Estrogen is the predominant hormone in women during both premenopausal and postmenopausal time periods. Estrogens play an important role throughout breast carcinogenesis, from influencing risk, to the development of contralateral breast cancer, to the progression of primary breast and metastatic breast cancer. These actions are achieved primarily through estrogenic actions on breast epithelial cells, however there is important evidence that immune cells contain estrogen receptors (ERs) and are regulated by estrogens as well. This would provide an important opportunity for estrogens to influence immunosurveillance, as well as the development and progression of breast cancer. Estrogenic actions result from binding to cytoplasmic receptors ERα and ERβ and activation of genomic pathways, although estrogens may also activate growth factor receptor activity with signaling through nongenomic pathways by ligand-independent ERα signaling involving binding of E2 to a membrane-anchored receptor, the G protein–coupled estrogen receptor 1 (GPER1), with subsequent activation of G proteins.
Immune cells of both the innate (dendritic cells, macrophages, neutrophils) and adaptive (CD4+, CD8+, B cells) cell types, and in both normal tissue and in breast cancer, have been shown to possess ERs and to be responsive to estrogens.
The response of immune cells to the estrogenic effects may include altered immune cell proliferation, secretion of cytokines, chemokines, and growth factors.
In breast cancer the distribution of immune cell types may vary according to tumor subtype as well as between stroma and tumor parenchyma (see below). The distribution of immune cells between stroma and parenchyma/ductal epithelium provides an opportunity for these cells, after estrogen stimulation, to influence multiple components of the microenvironment including other immune cells, epithelial cells, fibroblasts, adipose cells and endothelium. Ultimately, the response of immune cells will also be influenced by cell density, estrogen levels, ECM composition, blood supply, and the specific ER stimulated.
Although estrogens are probably the major steroid that influences cell behavior, it is recognized that these cells may also contain receptors for other steroids, including progesterone, glucocorticoids, and androgens,
and respond and be influenced by these hormones as well. Together, the cellular responsiveness of immune cells to estrogens (and other hormones) further clarifies events regulating progression in carcinogenesis, as well as suggest an additional potentially important role for antiestrogen therapy.
Immune Cells in Ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS)
DCIS is an important precursor lesion for invasive ductal carcinoma and accounts for 16% of all breast cancers annually in the United States.
DCIS contains, TILs and multiple studies have examined TIL in DCIS both according to cell density, according to the presence of aggressive features, and according to cell type. DCIS is characterized by an increase in the density and extent of immune cell infiltration compared to normal breast tissue.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
High-grade DCIS has significantly higher percentages of FOXP3+ cells, CD68+ and CD68+PCNA+ macrophages, human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DR+ cells, CD4+ T cells, CD20+ B cells, and total TILs compared to non–high-grade DCIS.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
noted a marked increase in the density of mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrates, including CD20+, CD68+, CD3+ and granzyme B+ cytotoxic T cells from normal breast tissue to DCIS to invasive breast cancer. On average, ER− DCIS has been found to contain higher numbers of all TIL subsets than ER+ DCIS, and ER+ DCIS was more likely to have to have a high CD8/FOXP3 ratio (> 4) than ER− DCIS.
observed that CD3+ T cells predominated across all DCIS subtypes at all ages, with slightly more CD4+ T cells than CD8+T cells on average. CD20+ B cells were the next most common TILs, followed by FOXP3+ T regulatory cells (Tregs). Others have observed B cells in DCIS and in invasive carcinoma, which were typically found in perivascular locales clustering in aggregates with T cells, forming ectopic follicles,
There is evidence also that TILs in DCIS are immunosuppressive. Programmed death ligand 1 (PD-L1) is an immunosuppressive surface ligand on lymphocytes; Thompson et al
demonstrated that 81% of DCIS lesions contained PD-L1+ TILs. They considered this to suggest an active immune response within DCIS and supported TIL expression of PD-L1 as a marker of downregulation of the body’s immune response within DCIS. FOXP3+ Treg cells are another important immunosuppressive cell that are increased in DCIS,
and are associated with high nuclear grade, comedo-type necrosis, hormone receptor (HR) negativity, high Ki-67 proliferation index, and p53 overexpression.
found the high infiltration of FOXP3+ TIL and the presence of PD-L1+ immune cells were associated with tumor recurrence in patients with pure DCIS. Pure DCIS associated with higher numbers of B lymphocytes has also been shown to be associated with a shorter recurrence-free interval (P = .04).
observed high numbers of FOXP3+ regulatory T cells identified in patients with DCIS at increased risk of relapse (P = .04). CD8+ HLA-DR+ T cells, CD8+ HLA-DR− T cells, and CD115+ cell populations have also shown to be associated with risk of recurrence.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
This is best illustrated by studies comparing the immune cell distribution in breast cancer and related normal breast tissue. In a study of mastectomy specimens utilizing immunohistochemistry (IHC) and flow cytometry, Ruffell et al
observed that breast cancer tissues contained infiltrates dominated by CD8+ and CD4+ lymphocytes, with minor populations of NK cells and B lymphocytes, whereas in the normal breast tissue myeloid-lineage cells including macrophages, mast cells, and neutrophils were more evident. A similar immune profile was observed in breast tissues obtained in prophylactic mastectomy tissue. Activated T lymphocytes also predominated in tumor tissue, with both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells displaying increased expression of activation markers CD69 and HLA-DR. They concluded these findings indicated a shift within tumors toward a Th2-type response in breast cancer characterized by the increased presence of B cells and CD4+ T cells, in comparison with normal breast tissue.
compared by singe cell sequencing the immune cell distribution in breast cancer with that of normal adjacent breast tissue. They found a significant increase in the diversity of cell states, reflected in an increase in variance of gene expression, among T cells, monocytes, and NK cells in tumor compared to normal tissue. This suggested that the increased heterogeneity of cell states and marked phenotypic expansions found within the tumor were likely due to more diverse local microenvironments within the tumor.
Two small studies utilizing high-throughput sequencing of the TCR beta chain to characterize diversity of the T-cell infiltrate have been performed. Beausang et al
demonstrated that there are unique compartments of enriched clonotypes in tumor and tumor-adjacent normal breast tissue, as well as identifying sequences shared among patients and unlikely to be involved in specific tumor recognition. Park et al
studied tumors before and after neoadjuvant therapy, and demonstrated a clonal expansion and decrease in diversity in those patients with pathologic complete response (pCR) to therapy.
The complexity of the composition of immune cells in breast cancer reflects a cross-talk between components of the innate immune response as it regulates the tumor microenvironment and the polarity of the adaptive immune response within that tumor.
Lymphocytes of the myeloid lineage, ie, tumor-associated macrophages, myeloid-derived suppressor cells, and dendritic cells, can create immunostimulatory or immunosuppressive milieus that affect the fate of T cells capable of homing to the tumor. In turn, macrophage polarization can be driven to M1 or M2 phenotypes by the cytokines expressed by cytotoxic or regulatory T cells.
Within breast cancer, the distribution of immune cells may also differ between the tumor parenchyma and stroma. In a study of breast cancer mastectomy specimens, immune cells were delineated in the tumors and surrounding stroma by IHC staining to identify CD3 (T cells), CD20 (B cells), CD68 (macrophages), and granzyme B (cytotoxic subset of CD3+ cells).
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
The breast samples ranged the spectrum of breast disease: normal, benign proliferative disease (usual ductal hyperplasia), DCIS, and invasive ductal carcinoma. Although there was a progressive increase in all cell types in both the parenchyma and stroma moving from normal mammary tissue to ductal carcinoma, the most striking difference from benign proliferative disease to DCIS to invasive cancer was the influx of CD3+ cells in the stroma of the latter two tissue types: average 4.2 cells/mm2 versus 46.6 cells/mm2 versus 77.0 cells/mm2, respectively (Figure 2). Interestingly, increases in the cytotoxic subset (granzyme B) were restricted to immune cells in the parenchyma: 16.3 versus 0.7 cells/mm2 in the parenchyma versus stroma of invasive cancer.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
in their review, similarly found that the incidence of stromal TIL (sTIL) ranged from 15% to 25%, whereas intratumoral TIL ranged from 5% to 10%. As will be discussed below, sTILs also have important prognostic value.
Figure 2Immune Cells in Breast Proliferative Disease and Breast Cancer. Immune Cells, including CD68+ (Macrophages/Monocytes), CD3+ (CD4+, CD8+), and Cytotoxic Lymphocytes (CTL) are Present in Breast Proliferative Disease and Increase in the Parenchyma and Stroma With Progression to Breast Cancer. Relative Increases for Each Cell Type, With Benign Proliferation as a Baseline, are Shown on a Logarithmic Scale in the Graphs Below the Figure. (Adapted from Data from within Hussein and Hassan
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
Immune Cell Distribution According to Breast Cancer Subtype
The distribution of TIL varies quantitively and qualitatively according to subtype in breast cancer. This has been demonstrated in several series. Stanton et al,
in a review of 13,914 patients, found a median of 20% of patients with TNBC demonstrated lymphocyte-predominant breast cancer (LPBC; ≥ 50%-60% lymphocytic infiltrate) at the time of diagnosis compared to 16% of HER2+ tumors and 6% of HR+ cancers. A median of 60% of TNBC samples had infiltrating CD8+ T cells in contrast to only 43% of HR+ tumors. TNBC tumors were also more likely to have FOXP3+ infiltrates than the HR+ subtype. Their findings indicated that HR-positive disease may be the least immunogenic of the common breast cancer subtypes. Liu et al,
in another study, reported a high density infiltration of Treg and FOXP3P+Tumor, but not CD8+Tumor, correlated significantly with HER2 overexpression. Increased infiltration of Tregs and cytotoxic lymphocytes was significantly more common in those tumors with unfavorable histologic features, including high histologic grade and negative ER and progesterone receptor status. They proposed that further studies to explore the functional status and action modes of cytotoxic lymphocytes and Tregs in different tissue locations and in different breast cancer subtypes will lead to a better understanding of the nature of breast carcinoma immunity. Denkert et al
Tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes and prognosis in different subtypes of breast cancer: a pooled analysis of 3771 patients treated with neoadjuvant therapy.
observed the percentage of tumors with high TILs was higher in TNBC (30%) and HER2-positive breast cancer (19%) than in luminal–HER2–negative tumors (13%) (P < .0001). Their data supported the hypothesis that breast cancer is immunogenic and might be targetable by immune-modulating therapies. Mohamed et al
CD8+ tumor infiltrating lymphocytes strongly correlate with molecular subtype and clinico-pathological characteristics in breast cancer patients from Sudan.
reported HER2/neu-positive breast cancer had a significantly higher CD8+ content (26.1%) compared to luminal A (13.5%), luminal B (17.0%), or TNBC (14.5%). This, however, did not apply to CD3+ or CD45RO+ type cells, and there was no significant correlation between CD45RO+ TILs and clinicopathologic parameters. Their study was conducted in the Sudan, and their finding that a higher CD8+ content was observed in HER2/neu-positive breast cancer is in agreement with the other studies, and suggests that the biological factors regulating TIL distribution according to subtype in North Africa may be similar to those in the United States.
Mutational Load of Breast Cancer Cells
The finding that immune cell types in breast cancer varied according to breast cancer subtype suggested the mutational load of breast cancer subtypes may also vary. When this was studied it was found there are also striking differences in the mutational load of breast cancer between subtypes. The genomic characteristics of each subtype has recently been analyzed and presented in detail in an analysis of cancer-adjacent breast tissue from The Cancer Genome Atlas Network.
The findings for different subtypes can be summarized as follows: the overall mutation rate was lowest in luminal A subtype and highest in the basal like and HER2 enriched (HER2E) subtypes. The luminal A subtype harbored the most significantly mutated genes, with the most frequent being PIK3CA (45%), followed by MAP3K1, GATA3, TP53, CDH1 and MAP2K4. Twelve percent of luminal A tumors contained likely inactivating mutations in MAP3K1 and MAP2K4. TP53 and PIK3CA mutations were the most common in Luminal B cancer (29% each); this contrasted with basal-like tumors where TP53 mutations occurred in 80% but PIK3CA mutations were absent or rare. Ten percent of sporadic breast cancer may have a strong germline contribution. Luminal tumors were mostly diploid whereas luminal B tumors were mostly aneuploid. Regarding HER2+ tumors, there are at least two types of clinically defined HER2 tumors, luminal messenger RNA (mRNA)-subtype/HER2+ tumors, and HER2E-mRNA subtype (HER2 enriched). A comparison identified 302 differentially expressed genes. The HER2E mRNA subtype typically showed high aneuploidy, the highest somatic mutation rate, and DNA amplification of other potential therapeutic targets including fibroblast growth factor receptors, epidermal growth factor receptor, CDK4, and cyclin D1. TP53 mutations were significantly enriched in HER2E or ER− tumors whereas GATA3 mutations were only observed in luminal subtypes or ER+ tumors. The basal-like subtype included TNBC (75%) as well as other mRNA subtypes (25%), and showed basal-like tumors with a high frequency of TP53 mutations (80%). PIK3CA was mutated in 9% of cases; however, inferred PI(3)K pathway activity, whether from gene, protein, or high PI(3)K/AKT pathway activities was highest in basal-like cancers. Expression features showed high expression of genes associated with cell proliferation. Although chromosome 8q24 is amplified across all subtypes, high MYC activation seems to be a basal-like characteristic. Other major genomic changes include ATM mutations (3%), BRCA1 (30%) and BRCA2 (6%) inactivation, RB1 loss (20%), and cyclin E1 amplification (9%). Together, these findings indicate a significant mutational burden across breast cancer subtypes. This may have important clinical, therapeutic, and biological implications. A high mutational burden would be associated with increased genomic instability and neoantigen development, increased cell injury and death, and development of chronic inflammation. At the same time altered secretion of secretory products could influence the activity, distribution, and interaction of associated immune and other cell types.
Nature of Immune Cells in Tertiary Lymph Structures in Breast Cancer
Tertiary lymph structures (TLS) (aka tertiary lymph organs) are ectopic lymphoid organs that develop at sites of chronic inflammation including autoimmune diseases, infection, and tumors. TLS have a defined structure, are comprised of multiple cell types including both innate (dendritic, macrophages, neutrophils) and adaptive (B cells, T cells) as well as plasma cells and high endothelial venules (HEV).
The TLS may be within the tumor or in a peritumoral location. TLS are generally associated with tumors with a more aggressive phenotype such as high-grade tumors, TNBC, and HER2+ tumors.
CD8+ tumor infiltrating lymphocytes strongly correlate with molecular subtype and clinico-pathological characteristics in breast cancer patients from Sudan.
reported TLS were associated with higher tumor grade, apocrine phenotype, necrosis, extensive in-situ component, lymphovascular invasion, high TIL, HR negativity, HER2 positivity, and c-kit expression. A favorable impact of TLS density on overall survival (OS) and disease-free survival (DFS) of patients has been observed.
CD8+ tumor infiltrating lymphocytes strongly correlate with molecular subtype and clinico-pathological characteristics in breast cancer patients from Sudan.
High endothelial venule blood vessels for tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes are associated with lymphotoxin beta-producing dendritic cells in human breast cancer.
Predictive value of tertiary lymphoid structures assessed by high endothelial venule counts in the neoadjuvant setting of triple-negative breast cancer.
An important component of TLS are HEV. These are specialized postcapillary venules found in lymphoid tissues that support high levels of lymphocyte extravasation from the blood.
High densities of tumor HEVs correlated with increased naive, central memory and activated effector memory T-cell infiltration and upregulation of genes related to T-helper 1 adaptive immunity and T-cell cytotoxicity.
high densities of tumor HEVs independently conferred a lower risk of relapse and significantly correlated this activity with longer metastasis-free, disease-free, and OS rates. Together, the presence and characteristics of TLS have important clinical implications: their presence in poor-prognosis tumors may be important both for selection of therapy and entry into clinical trials. The identification of an organized immune cell collection with effector memory cells in and adjacent to breast cancer and capable of antitumor activity may encourage efforts to promote its development and expansion in these tumors. The presence in TLS of HEVs that can enhance movement of lymphocytes into these tumors also encourages efforts to identify agents that can promote the activity of these vessels.
Immune Cells as a Prognostic Biomarker
With renewed interest in immune cells, investigators have interrogated large prospectively collected patient samples associated with seminal clinical trials to evaluate the role of immune cells as prognostic markers. The first of these studies was reported by Denkert et al
after analysis of the GeparDuo and GeparTrio trial cohorts. Pretreatment core biopsy samples of tumor and stroma were analyzed for lymphocytic infiltrate evaluated by routine hematoxylin and eosin staining. Two categories of immune infiltrate were defined: iTu-Ly (intratumoral lymphocytes) in direct contact with tumor cells or within tumor cell nests and str-Ly (stromal lymphocytes) without direct contact with tumor cells. LPBC was defined as tumors with > 60% of either iTu-Ly or str-Ly and represented 11% of the study population. LPBC demonstrated an increased incidence of pCR (10/24, 41.7%) when compared to those tumors with no lymphocytic infiltrate (1/36, 2.8%) or focal infiltrate (17/158, 10.8%). This was also demonstrated in gene expression data of the same cohort.
In an analysis of the BIG 02-98 multi-institutional randomized phase 3 trial, increasing lymphocyte infiltration was associated with improved prognosis in the subgroup of node-positive patients with TNBC. LPBC represented only 10.6% of the TNBC cohort using a threshold of 50%, but prognosis improved linearly with each 10% increase in lymphocyte infiltration.
Prognostic and predictive value of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in a phase III randomized adjuvant breast cancer trial in node-positive breast cancer comparing the addition of docetaxel to doxorubicin with doxorubicin-based chemotherapy: BIG 02-98.
Tumor samples from patients in the Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) 1199 and 2197 trials have been analyzed for the presence of intraepithelial TIL or sTIL lymphocytes.
Prognostic value of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in triple-negative breast cancers from two phase III randomized adjuvant breast cancer trials: ECOG 2197 and ECOG 1199.
Overall, the median intraepithelial TIL score was 0%, and LPBC was again a minority of cases (4.4%), although over 80% of cancers had a sTIL score > 10. Higher sTIL scores were associated with better prognosis; for every 10% increase in sTILs, a 14% reduction of risk of recurrence or death was noted (P = .02), and an 18% reduction of risk of distant recurrence (P = .04), and 19% reduction of risk of death. However, in Liu et al,
the effects of CD8+Tumor infiltration, and the ratio of CD8+Tumor/FOXP3P+Tumor on OS and progression-free survival, were not significant, whereas patients with high FOXP3+Tumor had a significantly shorter OS (P = .007) and progression-free survival (P = .003) both in the ER+ and ER− groups. Interestingly, recent studies have indicated that the spatial location and organization of CD8+ TILs within the tumor may be important in relation to relapse-free survival.
reported that the presence of islands of infiltrating CD8+ T cells was more significantly associated with relapse-free survival than CD8+ T-cell infiltration into either tumor stroma or total tumor. The integrin CD103, a marker for tissue resident memory T cells (TRM) appeared to mediate localization into cancer islands within tumors. The TRM subset has been implicated in cancer surveillance of melanoma and lung cancer.
utilized single-cell RNA sequencing techniques to derive a CD8+ TRM signature from primary TNBC tumors; when applied to a bulk RNA data, the signature was associated with improved patient survival.
A review of 15 studies of TIL classification also identified differences in lymphocyte infiltration across tumor subtypes.
LPBC was more frequently identified in TNBC (20%) and HER2+ (16%) specimens than in HR+/HER2− tumors (6%). Efforts have been made to unify the classification of TILs within breast cancer specimens, with a focus on stromal lymphocytes as the most reproducible and significant prognostic indicator of likelihood of response.
Tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes and prognosis in different subtypes of breast cancer: a pooled analysis of 3771 patients treated with neoadjuvant therapy.
of pooled data from the German Breast Cancer Group, classification of tumors by degree of stromal lymphocyte invasion allowed prediction of response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy in all molecular subtypes, but differences in survival outcomes may suggest a different biology of the immunologic infiltrate in HR+ tumors. Although pCR was attained in 28% of luminal HER2− tumors with high TILs (> 60%) compared to 6% and 11% in low (≤ 10%) and intermediate TILs, the presence of TILs was associated with shorter OS in that subtype. TNBC with high TILs demonstrated a higher pCR rate (50% high vs. 31% intermediate and low) and was associated with longer DFS and OS. The gains were more modest in HER2+ tumors with a 48% pCR rate in high TILs specimens versus 39% in intermediate and 32% in low samples, but still associated with longer DFS.
Tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes and prognosis in different subtypes of breast cancer: a pooled analysis of 3771 patients treated with neoadjuvant therapy.
Together, these findings support a prognostic role of TILs in breast cancer. The prognostic significance may correlate inversely with tumor HR status, suggesting there may also be a prominent hormonal influence on these lymphocytes in HR+ tumors.
Lastly, the effect of neoadjuvant chemotherapy on immune cell distribution has also been examined. In the study of Ruffell et al
their findings suggested that neoadjuvant chemotherapy further altered the complexity of the immune microenvironment of the residual tumors. They found residual tumors treated with neoadjuvant chemotherapy contained increased percentages of infiltrating myeloid cells, accompanied by an increased CD8/CD4 T-cell ratio and higher numbers of granzyme B–expressing cells, compared to tumors not treated with neoadjuvant chemotherapy. The effect of chemotherapy has also been examined by García-Martínez et al,
who evaluated tumors using IHC to define CD3+ cells, subsets of CD4+ and CD8+ cells, and the presence of B cells and monocytes before and after neoadjuvant chemotherapy.
They observed a decrease in the number of CD3+ cells after chemotherapy and a decrease in the CD4:CD8 ratio. They concluded that an IHC-based profile of immune cell subpopulations in breast cancer is able to identify a group of tumors highly sensitive to neoadjuvant chemotherapy.
Immune-Based Therapies for Breast Cancer
The majority of the studies of lymphocytes in breast cancer has focused on characterizing the nature of the lymphocyte infiltrate, with some gene expression data that may hint at the functional role of these cells in an anticancer response. Chemokines thought to be responsible for lymphocyte migration and gene expression signatures associated with Type I effector responses have been shown to correlate with pCR.
Programmed death receptor 1 (PD-1) and one of its ligands (PD-L1) have also been correlated with higher pCR rate and improved prognosis in breast cancer.
Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes and PD-L1 expression in pre- and posttreatment breast cancers in the SWOG S0800 phase II neoadjuvant chemotherapy trial.
These molecules are part of the immune checkpoint pathway that limits T-cell response. PD-L1 gene expression of immune cells in breast cancer has been shown to be positively associated with CD8+ and CD4+ memory-activated T cells, but not with CD4+ memory resting or T-regulatory cells or other immune cell subpopulations.
Programmed death-ligand 1 gene expression is a prognostic marker in early breast cancer and provides additional prognostic value to 21-gene and 70-gene signatures in estrogen receptor–positive disease.
In other histologies, expression of PD-L1 may correlate with response to checkpoint inhibition, but there are significant challenges to its use as a predictive biomarker, highlighted by the KEYNOTE-86 trial of pembrolizumab in patients with TNBC in which PD-L1 status was not the strongest discriminator between those with disease that did and did not respond to therapy.
The overall response rate in that trial was 18.5%. Similarly modest results were seen in an ER+ population in KEYNOTE-28 with an overall response rate of 12%.
Safety and antitumor activity of pembrolizumab in patients with estrogen receptor-positive/human epidermal growth factor receptor 2–negative advanced breast cancer.
Checkpoint inhibitors have been combined with chemotherapy demonstrating improvement in median OS, more pronounced in those patients with PD-L1+ tumors (Impassion130 trial),
A comprehensive review of current and proposed combination strategies identified 13 ongoing randomized phase 3 clinical trials investigating the strategy in patients with breast cancer.
Given the presence of an immune infiltrate in stages as early as DCIS, strategies to boost the immune response to potential tumor antigens by vaccination have been explored in prevention, adjuvant, neoadjuvant and metastatic settings.
Additional efforts explore the use of tumor ablative strategies (ie, cryoablation, radiofrequency ablation, stereotactic radiation) for potential release of tumor-associated antigens in conjunction with checkpoint inhibitor monoclonal antibodies to increase response rates.
Immuno-oncology and its opportunities for interventional radiologists: immune checkpoint inhibition and potential synergies with interventional oncology procedures.
A recent review highlighted the ways that the field of breast cancer immuno-oncology is building on information about TIL phenotypes to branch into different promising avenues of research.
Few groups have studied the phenotype and function of TILs cultured from freshly resected breast cancer. In the Surgery Branch of the National Cancer Institute, TILs derived from fragments of metastatic breast cancer and cultured in IL-2 were predominantly CD4+, in contrast to our experience with metastatic melanoma-derived TILs, which are predominantly CD8+ cells.
Randomized, prospective evaluation comparing intensity of lymphodepletion before adoptive transfer of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes for patients with metastatic melanoma.
Whole exome sequencing of the resected tumor identified candidate neoepitopes for further study, and TIL cultures were capable of identifying neoantigens processed by autologous antigen-presenting cells in vitro, in both class I and class II restricted fashion.
In a study of primary breast tumors, another group used an agonistic antibody against 4-1BB/CD137 during the initial TIL cultures and were able to generate more robust CD8+ populations. In two of these patient-derived cultures, the expanded CD8+ TILs were capable of mutation-specific recognition of class I predicted neoepitopes.
Tumor-specific TIL could be utilized to identify tumor neoantigens that could then be utilized in patient-specific vaccine strategies or to create cell-based treatments with autologous TIL or TIL-derived TCR gene-engineered products. We recently demonstrated proof of principle in a single case report of complete regression of refractory metastatic breast cancer after adoptive cell transfer with IL-2 and pembrolizumab.
Immune cells are identified in breast tissue throughout carcinogenesis, beginning in normal breast tissue in women at normal risk for breast cancer and continuing through breast cancer primary tumors and breast cancer metastases. The immune cells in normal breast tissue may play an important role in immunosurveillance and clarify our understanding of the prevention (and development) of early events in breast carcinogenesis. Our understanding of TILs is increasing dramatically. These cells have prognostic value for breast cancer outcomes and serve in adoptive transfer and other capacities to treat disseminated breast cancer. This knowledge is allowing us to recognize and to modify T cells in multiple ways, including selection of tumor neoantigen-specific T cells, to the engineering of TCRs to recognize specific tumor associated neoantigens and to insert these TCR into lymphocytes (including peripheral blood lymphocytes), for the development of vaccines that recognize tumor-specific antigens in breast cancer metastases. Together, these findings allow immunology and immunotherapy to serve as the major fourth modality for the management of patients with cancer, alongside surgery, chemotherapy, and radiotherapy. This should greatly improve our ability to prevent and treat breast cancer, as well as many other malignancies.
Disclosure
The authors have stated that they have no conflict of interest.
Acknowledgment
This research was supported by the Intramural Research Program, Center for Cancer Research, National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD.
Analysis of immune cells from human mammary ductal epithelial organoids reveals Vdelta2+ T cells that efficiently target breast carcinoma cells in the presence of bisphosphonate.
Analysis of the mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltrate in the normal breast, benign proliferative breast disease, in situ and infiltrating ductal breast carcinomas: preliminary observations.
Prognostic and predictive value of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in a phase III randomized adjuvant breast cancer trial in node-positive breast cancer comparing the addition of docetaxel to doxorubicin with doxorubicin-based chemotherapy: BIG 02-98.
Prognostic value of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in triple-negative breast cancers from two phase III randomized adjuvant breast cancer trials: ECOG 2197 and ECOG 1199.
Overexpressed genes associated with hormones in terminal ductal lobular units identified by global transcriptome analysis: an insight into the anatomic origin of breast cancer.
Tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes and prognosis in different subtypes of breast cancer: a pooled analysis of 3771 patients treated with neoadjuvant therapy.
CD8+ tumor infiltrating lymphocytes strongly correlate with molecular subtype and clinico-pathological characteristics in breast cancer patients from Sudan.
High endothelial venule blood vessels for tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes are associated with lymphotoxin beta-producing dendritic cells in human breast cancer.
Predictive value of tertiary lymphoid structures assessed by high endothelial venule counts in the neoadjuvant setting of triple-negative breast cancer.
Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes and PD-L1 expression in pre- and posttreatment breast cancers in the SWOG S0800 phase II neoadjuvant chemotherapy trial.
Programmed death-ligand 1 gene expression is a prognostic marker in early breast cancer and provides additional prognostic value to 21-gene and 70-gene signatures in estrogen receptor–positive disease.
Safety and antitumor activity of pembrolizumab in patients with estrogen receptor-positive/human epidermal growth factor receptor 2–negative advanced breast cancer.
Immuno-oncology and its opportunities for interventional radiologists: immune checkpoint inhibition and potential synergies with interventional oncology procedures.
Randomized, prospective evaluation comparing intensity of lymphodepletion before adoptive transfer of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes for patients with metastatic melanoma.
30155-5&id=gr1.jpg){kind=link}
30155-5&id=gr2.jpg){kind=link}